PriceLabs Study: Hotel Guests Now Open to Short-Term Rentals

A new PriceLabs study finds that 82% of guests who stay at B&Bs, inns, or small hotels would consider a short-term rental if prices are similar. Independent hotels face far more competition from rentals than large chains, with booking platforms accelerating this blending of accommodation categories.
Lines Between Hotels and Rentals Continue to Blur
A new study by revenue management software provider PriceLabs has found that the traditional divide between hotels and short-term rentals is rapidly disappearing in the eyes of travellers. According to the research, 82% of guests who booked a bed-and-breakfast, inn, or small hotel said they would seriously consider a short-term rental for their trip if the price were comparable.
The survey, which covered more than 1,000 travellers across the US, UK, France, Spain, and Portugal, suggests that independent and boutique properties are facing significantly more competition from the rental segment than large hotel chains do.
Independent Hotels Feel the Pressure
The data shows that 30% of guests who booked a B&B or small hotel also weighed a short-term rental option for the same trip. In comparison, only 16% of large hotel chain guests did the same — meaning independent properties face nearly double the competitive pressure from the rental market.
This has clear implications for boutique and heritage hotels in India as well, many of which compete directly with the growing supply of serviced apartments, villas, and holiday homes listed on rental platforms, particularly in leisure destinations like Goa, the hills of Himachal Pradesh, and coastal Gujarat.
Booking Platforms Drive Comparison Shopping
The study highlights the role booking platforms play in encouraging guests to compare hotels and rentals side by side. On platforms such as Booking.com, which list both categories together, 45% of guests compared hotel and rental options before finalising their booking. This figure dropped to just 29% when guests booked directly through a property's own website or front desk.
With Airbnb increasingly adding hotel listings to its platform, PriceLabs suggests hoteliers now have a growing opportunity to reach travellers who might otherwise default to rental bookings, provided they actively list and price competitively on these hybrid platforms.
Prices Moving in Sync
Perhaps the most telling finding is how closely hotel and rental pricing now track each other in popular destinations. In Mallorca, hotel and rental rates showed a 94% correlation throughout the year, while Barcelona recorded an 84% correlation. This indicates that pricing in both segments responds to the same seasonal demand patterns, rather than operating as separate markets.
Frequently Asked Questions
What did the PriceLabs study find about hotel guests?
The study found that 82% of guests who stayed at B&Bs, inns, or small hotels would consider a short-term rental if the price were similar, showing reduced brand loyalty based on property type.
Are independent hotels more affected than large chains?
Yes, independent hotels face nearly double the competition from short-term rentals, with 30% of their guests also considering rentals compared to 16% for large hotel chain guests.
How do booking platforms influence this trend?
Platforms like Booking.com, which list both hotels and rentals together, saw 45% of guests comparing both options, versus just 29% when booking directly with a property.
Is this trend relevant to Indian hoteliers?
Yes, as rental platforms expand in Indian leisure markets, boutique and independent hotels may face similar pricing competition and should adopt data-driven revenue strategies.
Get Full Itinerary on WhatsApp
Share your details and we'll send you the complete travel plan!


